Blogging on Issues of International and European Security

Syria: what impact for the Region and Partners?

Source: ISIS Europe archive

Source: ISIS Europe archive

by Elena Marda

The events in Brussels about the Syrian conflict are numerous. The event organised by the German Marshall Fund of the United States  consisted in a discussion between Professor Eyal Zisser Dean at Tel Aviv University, Ambassador Marc Pierini, Visiting Scholar at Carnegie Europe, and was moderated by Sir Michael Leigh, Senior Advisor at the German Marshall Fund of the United States. During the discussion one question kept coming back: which of the involved parties will define the course of the battle? And most importantly, how?

The unique characteristics of the conflict, the limited action that accompanies the EU and the US, the risk of spill-over effects in the region and the posture of different actors are creating a complicated environment for conflict management. The following factors were identified as the main reasons for the existing deadlock in Syria:

1) Fragmentation – The rebels do not have a unified command structure, while the presence of local militias is further shattering their organisation. In addition, by failing to reach the population in big cities, the conflict is restrained to a ‘peasant revolt’ as described by Professor Zisser. It is only recently that, groups other than the Islamist militias,started organising civilian administration (hospitals, food, and distribution of aid) in the liberated areas of the country.

2) Indifference – The Assad family has already demonstrated that it is primarily concerned about only that part of the country which represents for them the centre of power; Damascus, the coast line and the zone in-between. Moreover, the Syrian bureaucracy is still functioning and the minority communities retain their support for the regime.

3) Security risks – The US administration, having taken into consideration the lessons learned from Iraq and Afghanistan, are reluctant to intervene as the actual situation on the ground is  uncertain.

The two speakers agreed on the key player of the conflict: Russia. They shattered any illusions that Russia’s position has anything to do with Syria per se, and they linked its current posture to the UNSC Resolution on Libya and its pursuit to re-establish the Russian state in the new world order. According to Ambassador Pierini neither Iran, nor Hezbollah suffice to help the Syrian regime to win the battle.

Finally they gave only little hope that the lifting of the arms embargo would be a game changer. The balance of power is extremely hard to change without a shift in the Kremlin’s position. The only way that this could be achieved is if Russian interests can be served by a different actor than Assad. Moreover, providing sophisticated weapons would require the US to send its own staff to assist the rebels, something that is highly unlikely to happen, at least for the time being.

Finally the participants made recommendations to the US and the EU. Ambassador Pierini warned that any kind of intervention by the western community would be considered as an aggression towards Russia. He suggested that enhancing the humanitarian assistance provided at the local level will be beneficial in the long term. Professor Zisser presented two different options; the western states should either acknowledge their defeat and stop supporting opposition forces, or they should increase their level of implication and intervene in a pragmatic way.

You can visit our SYRIA FOCUS page here

2 comments on “Syria: what impact for the Region and Partners?

  1. TheTruthMedium
    26/06/2013

    Europe and the USA watched silently when Bosnian were getting massacred and the reaction was then a delayed one after many thousands had died. We see a repeat of that scenario in Syria. The Russian government again taking the side of the oppressor (at least doing something) while others watch. But where is humanity? Surely the Russian see good in selling their weapons and securing arms deal with the Assad regime a higher obligation than protecting civilians who are dying in the middle. But a solution can’t be seen in arming the rebels, with the Western world fears of the unknown especially with Al Qaeda affiliated groups like Al Nusra front. Despite, arming the rebels was already taking place, although in directly via Saudi and Qatari channels.
    What Syria needs now is not escalating the conflict by arming one side, but rather actions from the powerful nations. Forcing Assad to step down and punished for his actions through a fair justice system so the Syrian people get some dignity back, pressuring the Russians to stop their support, large humanitarian activities to help the millions of displaced and homeless refugees and finally disarming the entire population as everyone in Syria now seems to carry a weapon, to then help build a strong Police and armed forces. But at the end of the day everyone remembers how the peaceful protests in Daraa became the War Within after the brutality of a regime.

    • ISIS Europe
      26/06/2013

      Thank you for your comment. Indeed, there are many similarities between Syria and the Bosnia case; but also differences that it would also be good to have in mind.Here you can find an interesting article on that perspective: http://www.lowyinterpreter.org/post/2013/06/25/Why-Syria-is-not-like-Bosnia.aspx

      Unfortunately, the conflict setting right now does not leave adequate space to the international community to be flexible. It is always useful to think of conflicts in terms of seasons; and at this point Syria is passing a season of violence. Perhaps, EU’s contribution – apart from providing humanitarian assistance – could be as a facilitator between US and Russia in order to overcome the deadlock within UNSC.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Twitter

Facebook

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 175 other followers

Archives

%d bloggers like this: